Thursday, December 5, 2019

Thoughts on Bless All the Dear Children



I've long said the final Christmas episode, "Bless All the Dear Children," is my least favorite Little House Christmas show. Recently, I watched this episode again. While my overall opinion hasn't changed, there are some good moments to celebrate or at least mention. Let's start with my nitpicks and then end with the positives.

Nitpicks

  • Pa's narration opens the episode by stating this story takes place in the winter of 1896. Rose Wilder was born in 1886. She would have been 10.
  • Pa also says that while they were used to cold winters, the winter of 1896 brought with it warm temperatures (hence people walking around with no coats and their sleeves rolled up in December in Minnesota). That year, the Midwest had experienced a long Indian summer, but by Thanksgiving temperatures were well below average with some areas reporting record breaking cold (-50).  
  • Mr. Edwards gets into a bar fight, which is why Almanzo leaves Rose and she is abducted. Didn't he pretty much stop drinking after the whole incident with Albert? 
  • Somehow Samuel hid in the back of their wagon undetected even though they had to ride half a day to get to their first stop?
  • Mr. Edwards doesn't apologize. Not when Almanzo feels guilty and breaks down or when Laura is upset they will never find Rose. 
  • The star in the sky leading them to Samuel after he runs away is just too corny for even me.
  • The Carters living in the little house on Plum Creek will never sit right with me. 

Enjoyable Moments
  • Seeing the family together and happy. The Wilders endured Almanzo's illness and paralysis, a tornado destroying their first house, the loss of Royal Wilder, the loss of Baby Wilder and Rose contracting small pox, Jenny Wilder almost dying twice, and the death of Laura's beloved brother, Albert. Thank goodness we see some happy times, too.
  • The way the actors portrayed a married couple in crisis. By now, they should be experts at it. We should remember, however, that neither was married and Melissa Gilbert was only 19 when this episode aired. 
  • Mr. Montague delivering presents to the Carters and Jenny Wilder dressed as Santa Claus. Though he rallied against the commercialization of Christmas--something I'm pretty sure never came up in the late 1800s--he puts aside his feelings when the Wilders are delayed and the Carters have nothing to give their boys. 
  • A strong Almanzo defending his family. When they find Rose, Patrick Norris still believes the story his wife has told him about the little girl she brought home belonging to them. It doesn't take long for him to grab his gun. Though Laura pleads with both men to stop it, Almanzo isn't about to back down from protecting his family. Seeing him so dedicated to his family is not new, but if you think to how despondent he was back when Rose was born and he thought he would never walk again, this strong protector is truly a different man.
  • Sam being adopted by Mr. and Mrs. Norris. Not sure everything was legal, but they all ended up happy.


What do you think about this episode? Do you share any of my nitpicks or enjoyable moments? Were there any other things that make it or break it for this episode?

6 comments:

Splenderella said...

Hi! Came upon your blogspot when I looked up info on the cast of "Bless All the Dear Children", while I was only halfway through the movie - watching for the first time! I was about to give up on it - slogging thru the obnoxious antics of junior narcissist Nancy Oleson, then the annoying whining of little Jason Carter after he decapitates a tree...but because of your comments, decided to stick with it a little farther! Parts I did enjoy: the lovely mom - Sara Carter, who reminded me of Carolyn Ingalls; the humble admission of guilt by Mrs.Norris when the Wilders confront the couple - she, fortunately, wasn't COMPLETELY insane, just temporarily unbalanced! Like you, I rolled my eyes at the "miraculous star" that was simply corny...but my favorite scene was Mr.Montague turning from Scrooge to Santa, and presenting just the right gifts to the Carter family - including the scarf for his mom that Jason had his heart set on! The tears in his eyes after Mrs.Carter followed him out and said he was loved was very touching - it was probably a type of human interaction the poor man had never experienced before, and hid under a mask of cynicism and sarcasm! ...and finally, of course, the adoption of Samuel - legal or not, that filled a need - "folks who want a son real bad!", and a little boy who needed a family real bad! This is the longest post I've ever made online, but it's been nice to respond to a fellow lover of the "Little House" series! All the best - and Merry Christmas!

Cheryl said...

I am so glad you stuck with the episode until the end.

Sara was a bit of Caroline in this episode. Mr. Montague was fabulous. I always loved his character.

Thanks for visiting. Merry Christmas!

angelbabe2207 said...

I loved it!! It’s TV. Who looks at the dates??? It was meant to be a loving scene. I didn’t nitpick none of the episodes…if only people of today were HALF this kind…….

Cheryl said...

I'm glad you enjoyed it, angelbabe2207.

Unknown said...

My biggest question about this movie was how they ended up near the Mexican border a couple days ride out of Mankato! The station agent said the train went all the way to Mexico for the same fare so the woman could be anywhere! Then, Laura clearly arrives in a border town, but when they find Rose, it looks to be MN again. That plus why the woman's husband left her alone so far away in a hospital to have her baby, then made her come home alone. Crazy!

Cheryl said...

Those horses were sure fast, right? Michael Landon didn't allow himself to get bogged down in the details. He focused on telling a good story. Of course, people weren't watching them all together like we do now. Some things probably got missed.